MINUTES  OF  THE  BOARD  OF  DIRECTORS,  DOUGLAS COUNTY HISTORICAL SOCIETY

April 24, 2007

Present:  Charles Thomas (new), Glee Smith, William Winkler (recording),  Bill Myers, P. Von Achen, J. Martin, President Sibley, Phyllis Tiffany, Leslie Miller, Linda Hyler, Matt Richards, James Dunn, Randy Van Schmus

 

Absent:  P. Humphrey, B. Waggoner , Bob Piller

 

Staff present:  Rebecca Phipps, Helen Krische, Kerry Lippencott\

 

The meeting was called to order by President Sibley at the Museum, 4 PM April 24.

 

As the meeting began, John Coffman, CMR Construction, assisted by Bo Hamby, reported on the state of plans for repair of the Watkins Museum of History slate roof.  He recapped the Sept. 26, 2006 report to the Society and noted that he had excellent help from the Museum staff and was able to do research on the past history of the building at University of Kansas. Records show that J. B. Watkins demanded a very perfect roof. Several inspections revealed that the roof, more than 100 years old, was damaged by the April 23, 2006, hail storm.  The red slate came from the only quarry that mines it, in Middle Granville, NY.  They are still in business; this slate was produced in 1886-87.

 

CMR initially proposed to have 1/3 of the slate pieces replaced, being nailed with copper nails to wood framing, and with a waterproof underlayment, not available in the nineteenth century.  Allied sent the Douglas County Historical Society a check for approximately $70,000 on April 12, 2007, for replacement of 100 pieces of slate, but did not include their engineer’s report. We have a $500 deductible. The Society sent the check back.

 

In September 2006, Craig LeGere, a member of the National Slate Association, determined that the slate damage was consistent with damage by hail, and 70% of the broken slate pieces counted, had splits.  Close up examination showed that 12.8% were damaged and needed replacement.  Coffman hired Haag Engineering of Dallas to assess the situation.  They are among the best in the country for this work.  Allied Insurance later tried to hire them, on November 17, which would be a conflict of interest.  The New Mexico engineers Allied hired to inspect the slate roof reported only minor damage.  However, Allied has not released their written report, which they said they would do on March 20, despite inquiries from Coffman. Haag made a second inspection of the roof on February 8. Their report is not complete as of April 24.

 

Coffman delivered 120 samples of our slate roof to Haag, at his expense of about $2000.  Haag’s testing on April 20 with new red slate did indeed indicate damage from hail, not old age.  This was the first time the engineers had ever made this test.  It was found that, however, it may not be possible to mix old and new slate to make a viable roof, even though color and texture are perfect; new slate will not lie perfectly flat against old.  In that case an entirely new slate roof will be needed.

 

A Chicago bidder offered a cost of more than $700,000 for a roof involving one-third replacement, blending and sealing, but the cost of extensive scaffolding, OSHA requirements and protecting against neighboring damage would be extra.  In this case, Coffman will absorb the cost difference between our insurance maximum of $1,355,000 and the cost of an entirely new roof.  He will keep the proceeds from sale of the damaged slate, which is widely reused. The Society will pay only its $500 deductible.  CMR plans to clean the whole exterior of the building during re-roofing.

 

The Middle Granville quarry will require months to produce the needed slate. Coffman will visit the quarry to monitor progress.  It may be autumn before roof repairs are begun.

 

The March minutes were approved by Hyler, seconded by Myers, with Tiffany’s correction that Barbara Ballard is not a current member of the Society.  So voted.

 

Treasurer’s Report

Myers handed out written reports for February and March, and discussed verbally. We are in the black with one-half of the Douglas County grant and $14,000 from the Richards Trust but could be broke by July without effective fund raising.  Our Investment Agency account (Springer stock donation) has grown 1.5% since December.  Likely there will be a budget hearing concerning DCHS at the Court House on Tuesday May 1.

 

Staff Reports

Written monthly summaries by Phipps, Krische, and Lippencott were provided.  There was discussion about the Director’s suggestion that our building be put on Lawrence’s register of historic places, as it is on the Federal and State.  This likely will happen, but requirements may be more complex; consult with the City’s Lynn Zollner is indicated.  Tiffany motioned, Myers seconded, that this idea go forward with the suggestions made, in effect tabled until then.  This registration could help our roof insurance and Lawrence Preservation Alliance procedures.

 

Two upcoming public programs were announced.  There are fliers and newspaper announcements.  It is expected that we can participate in the May 10 24 Hours in the Life of Lawrence.  Hyler is working on more effective school notification of Museum programs. There is a good prospect for a fiberglass museum sign when we have the money.

 

The draft of Museum Policies was approved unanimously by the Board.  It appears that the dinner dance on August 11 will be preceded by a catered dinner on the third floor of the Museum. Can’t dance up there.  We plan to start a program of breakfast and/or lunch speakers in September.  The new brochures on the Civil War on the American Frontier are due early in May.  The Annual Report is being printed for us by Allen Press.  More volunteer help is needed greeting visitors at the door on parts of Tuesday, Thursday, Friday, and Saturday.

 

Old Business

Hyler, Miller, and Krische are working on the August 5K run and walk formerly administered by Marcia Riley.  At each meeting Hyler will pass around a help sign up sheet.  Maybe Board members could sign up for seven jobs.  Permission to run the race through Oak Hill Cemetery is pending.  Need more sponsors and publicity.  The web site will be runlawrence.com.

 

We need an inventory policy for Miss Lizzie’s Gift Shop. Policy on key use will be considered in May.  The Museum media policies were approved as Tiffany moved acceptance, Martin seconded, so voted.

 

New Business

Myers suggested that current policies be collected into binders for new Board members.  A new date for our postponed January retreat is pending.  Dunn will be attending the Preservation Alliance and State Historical Society meetings.

 

Meeting adjourned at 6:07 PM.

 

NOTE next Board meeting, 4 PM on May 22.  I may not be back from travel on that date, so would appreciate a volunteer taking Minutes for me, and hold corrections until then.  The part of these minutes dealing with the roof repair have been approved by John Coffman.